Post in evidenza

Serial child rapist, killer sentenced to death #JusticeForZainab

LAHORE – An anti-terrorism court on Saturday found Imran Ali, prime accused in Zainab rape and murder in Kasur, guilty and award...


mercoledì 3 maggio 2017

Death Penalty for Extreme Depravity

Protesters demanding the death penalty

NEW DELHI:  A 55-year-old man who had raped and stoned to death a four-year-old girl will be hanged to death, the Supreme Court said today.
The court said the "extreme depravity" of the crime does not allow for any possible mitigating circumstances.

Vasanta Sampat Dupare, a resident of Nagpur, had killed the child in April 2008. He had lured her with chocolates and after raping her, crushed her head with stones to prevent identification. The man, who had four other criminal cases against him earlier, then hid the body.

Dupare was found guilty and sentenced to death. The sentence was upheld by the Bombay High Court in 2008. The Supreme Court confirmed it in November 2014, calling the crime "diabolical and barbaric".  

In its judgment, the top court had said, "This is not only betrayal of individual trust but destruction and devastation of social trust. It is perversity in its enormity".

From Nagpur jail, where he is currently lodged, Dupare had applied for a review. His lawyer argued that he had been deprived of an opportunity to make submissions.  The trial court, his lawyer said, had imposed the death sentence on him "on the very same day he was convicted in the case."

Refusing to review its sentence today, the top court said, "We have given anxious consideration to the issue   In view of the extreme depravity and barbaric manner in which crime was committed clearly out way the mitigating circumstances."

For Dupare, the next and the last step is appeal for a Presidential pardon.

NEW DELHI: A condemned prisoner's proficiency in Gandhian thoughts, drawing and painting skills and acquisition of a pre-bachelor degree in jail while awaiting execution failed to convince the Supreme Court on Wednesday about his reformation to spare him the gallows.

Facing death penalty for raping and brutally murdering his friend's four year-old daughter, the man could delay his execution by two and half years by requesting the SC to review the capital punishment saying he was on the path to reformation having acquired proficiency in Gandhian thoughts while in jail.

Nine years ago on April 3, 2008, Vasanta Sampat Dupare had lured the child with chocolates, raped her at an isolated place and battered her to death with a stone in Wadi police station area of Nagpur. He was sentenced to death by the trial court in 2012 and it was confirmed by Bombay HC.

SC had on November 26, 2014, affirmed death sentence finding it to be a 'rarest of rare' category case. It had said: "The injuries caused on the minor girl are likely to send a chill in the spine of the society and shiver in the marrows of human conscience. He had battered her to death by assaulting her with two heavy stones... After the savage act was over, the coolness of the appellant is evident, for he washed the clothes on the tap and took proper care to hide things.. The criminality of the conduct of the appellant is not only depraved and debased, but can have a menacing effect on the society. It is calamitous."

Appearing for Dupare, senior advocate Anup Bhambani, assisted by Nishant Gokhale of NLU-Delhi's Death Penalty Litigation Clinic, attempted to show to a bench of Justices Dipak Misra, R F Nariman and U U Lalit that the man, who had dropped out of school, has made serious attempt in jail to resume studies and got through examinations to prepare for a bachelors-level course.

"Dupare in 2015 also successfully completed the Gandhi Vichar Pariksha (Examination on Gandhian Thoughts). This examination seeks to rehabilitate prisoners who have committed violent crimes, by learning from the life and teaching of M K Gandhi," Bhambani said.

"During the period of incarceration, Dupare has undertaken studies, art competitions as well as several programmes aimed at reforming himself," the advocate further said.

The petitioner's drawings are exhibited in jail and he has participated in several drawing competitions," he said. Finally, he argued that the accused did not get adequate opportunity to present his arguments on the quantum of sentence before the trial court, which awarded death sentence two hours after convicting him of rape-murder.

The bench was unimpressed. It said: "We have given anxious consideration to the material on record but find that the aggravating circumstances namely the extreme depravity and the barbaric manner in which the crime was committed and the fact that the victim was a helpless girl of four years clearly outweigh the mitigating circumstances now brought on record."

"Having taken an overall view of the matter, in our considered view, no case is made out to take a different view in the matter," the bench said re-affirming the award of death penalty on Dupare.

Gandhian studies will not save rapist, killer of 4-yr-old from noose Dhananjay Mahapatra May 4, 2017

Infant rapist sentenced to death 3 maggio 2017

Ti piace?

Nessun commento:

Posta un commento

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...